YELTSIN'S FAREWELL
by
GWENDOLYN STEWART
BORIS YELTSIN'S G-8 FAREWELL
Cologne, Germany,
July 1999
Photograph by GWENDOLYN STEWART c. 2012
BOOK
REVIEW
By Gwendolyn Stewart, Boston GLOBE,
3/4/2001
Midnight Diaries By Boris Yeltsin (translated,
from the Russian, by Catherine A. Fitzpatrick)
When Boris Yeltsin last invited readers to share his
thoughts on his life and Russia's times, it was 1994. The Russian leader had just
''solved'' a constitutional crisis by sending tanks to rout Kremlin pretenders
from their stronghold in the Moscow White House - after they had fired the
first shots, of course.
''The Struggle for Russia,'' the second volume of what has now become a
Yeltsin trilogy, was his apologia for using force,
issued just as he was about to use force even more egregiously in
Chechnya. His earlier memoir, ''Against the Grain'' (1990), had been a
campaign biography, Yeltsin's self-introduction to Russia and the world.
Now, in the wake of his stunning millennial New Year's Eve resignation, comes
the ''Midnight Diaries,'' the summing up of his decade of power.
From the first to the last, these memoirs have featured breathtaking
candor, and giant gaps. This third volume is no exception.
He and his perennial collaborator-ghostwriter, Valentin Yumashev, know
what the controversial issues are, and address them
head on: the family (daughter Tatyana, yes, eminence grise Boris
Berezovsky, no, though crucial meetings seem to take place
in his offices); the oligarchs (necessary for the transitional phase);
corruption (none on his part!); his health (many new details,
not everything); his drinking (to relieve stress). He did, he admits,
contemplate canceling the 1996 presidential elections ''for two years.''
But the main theme of the book is Yeltsin's search for a successor to
take Russia out of the new Time of Troubles into which
it had fallen, ''the crisis era between two stable periods.'' So many
crises! Yeltsin has a long list of them, but, he argues, they
were not his fault. Society was divided, the president's legitimacy
constantly challenged. There were three serious attempts at
impeachment in the decade, plus the shadow of the threat of removal on
medical grounds hanging over his entire second term.
If ever there were a Faustian political bargain, Yeltsin's election
victory in 1996 would seem to be it. He ran in the face of
single-digit approval ratings, war in Chechnya, two heart attacks in
1995, and a communist victory in the December 1995
parliamentary elections. The communists, and much of the outside world,
assumed that their leader, Gennady Zyuganov, was
going to win the presidency in June 1996. With all the hype afterward
about the role of money and the media in that race, none
of it would have mattered without Yeltsin's own apparent return to vigor
in a tough campaign. What it cost him was his own
longer-term health. In ''Midnight Diaries,'' he actually names the date
of the heart attack that finally brought him down: June
26, one week before the deciding round of the election. What it cost
Russia, we will see.
It took Yeltsin eight months of his second term to mend enough to
fully command the Kremlin again. Typically, he chose to
try to speed up economic changes, this time with the aid of the ''young
reformers,'' Anatoly Chubais and Boris Nemtsov. He
also began in earnest his search for a successor. Just as Viktor
Chernomyrdin fancied himself growing nicely presidential,
Yeltsin dumped him. Five-plus years of one prime minister were followed
by four in 17 months, including Yevgeny
Primakov and Vladimir Putin.
But Yeltsin's position was weakened by his further illnesses, a
Russian
economic default and devaluation, and the scandals
that seemed to be drawing nearer to his own family, tempting other
''political heavyweights'' to jump in. The most formidable
challenge came from Mayor Yury Luzhkov, his former ally, using his Moscow
base as Yeltsin had once tried to use it against
Mikhail Gorbachev. Luzhkov hitched his star to Primakov's and gathered
support from the powerful regional governors.
Luzhkov, far more than Zyuganov the communist, is the subject of
Yeltsin's ire, even though ''Communist'' is his label of
choice to discredit his opponents.
In the end, Yeltsin is persuaded that he has found in Putin the young,
energetic, intellectual, democratic successor with a
''steel backbone'' that he had been seeking, and found him himself.
Whatever the importunings and strategizing of oligarchs
and favorites who might have tried to influence his choice, this is the
same Yeltsin who always loved the ''triuk,'' the trick,
the sharp unexpected move that catches one's opponent off balance.
Yeltsin explicitly acknowledges his decision to sacrifice
half a year of his own term to shorten the campaign by 10 weeks. Putin,
Yeltsin reveals, did not like public politics and
election campaigns. In this, the former KGB colonel was, at least
initially, very unlike Yeltsin, the former provincial
politician. Yeltsin used to mix right in with crowds and even sparked off
their challenging questions.
Yeltsin also meditates on Russia's role in the world since the end of
the Soviet megastate. That this breakup was relatively
bloodless is very much to his credit, part strategy, part inheritance
from the liberationist theology of Andrei Sakharov and
other liberal deputies in the first Soviet Congress of People's Deputies
with whom he served. Before Yeltsin ever stood on a
tank in front of the Moscow White House, he had flown to stand with the
Balts when they were under attack from
Gorbachev's tanks.
His initial economic plan was also a liberal one as understood by the
Washington consensus of the day. The first post-Soviet
Russian government, led by Yegor Gaidar, tried to break the hold of the
military-industrial-complex on the economy. The
withdrawal of Soviet-era troops from Central Europe was completed. NATO
responded by enlarging to Russia's borders. As
a reward - or a bribe? - for acquiescing, Russia was made a ''full''
member of what became the G-8.
Then NATO in its first hot war bombed Yugoslavia: ''Wasn't it obvious
to them that each missile strike against Yugoslavia
was an indirect strike against Russia?'' Yeltsin asks. Moscow helped
arrange a settlement, and then vented its frustrations by
deploying its paratroopers to the Pristina airport first. Tough rhetoric
was followed by the dramatic return to rapprochement at the G-8 summit in
Cologne. These developments are part of the legacy that Yeltsin left for
Putin. But Russia had never been more open to partnership with the United
States and the West than it was when Yeltsin began. George Bush could not
bring himself to respond in kind.
Will the first Russian president's vision of his own time as the
tumultuous interlude between two stable periods be proven
correct? And with what kind of stability? Laissez-faire, run riot, often
seemed the rule after the overthrow of the
hypercentralized Soviet Union. Corrections were due and overdue. But for
all its woes, Russia under Yeltsin did change in
positive directions, with significant segments of the population now
accustoming itself to the new society. Stay tuned.
Gwendolyn Stewart, an associate at Harvard's Davis Center for
Russian Studies, is writing her own account of the Yeltsin and Putin years.
This story ran on page C3 of the Boston Globe on 3/4/2001.
© Copyright 2001 Globe Newspaper Company.
GWENDOLYN STEWART is both a
photojournalist and a political scientist specializing in political
leadership in Russia, China, and the U.S. A former
Bunting/Radcliffe Fellow, she is an Associate (and former Post-Doctoral
Fellow) of the Davis Center for Russian Studies and Central Eurasian
Studies at Harvard, as well as an Associate in Research of the Harvard
Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies. For the Fairbank Center
she co-founded and co-chairs the China Current Events Workshop, a forum
for examining pressing issues in Greater China. Her Harvard
Ph.D. dissertation (Sic Transit) dealt with the role of the
leaders of the republics, especially Boris Yeltsin, in the breakup of the
Soviet Union. She is currently writing RUSSIA REDUX, the story of Russia under
Yeltsin and Putin, part political analysis, part travel-memoir:
Imagine wandering over the largest country on earth, not in the train
of a railroad, but in the train of one of the most powerful and
contradictory men on earth.
Or all by yourself. * * * * * * * * * * * * An exhibition of a quarter-century of the photography
of Gwendolyn Stewart entitled "HERE BE GIANTS"was held at
Harvard. * * * * * * * * BILL & BORIS & VLADIMIR
& GEORGE & Strobe Talbott's THE RUSSIA HAND: AMERICA'S RUSSIA
POLICY THE
PHOENIX: YELTSIN & THE FUTURE OF RUSSIAN LEADERSHIP THOMAS P.
O'NEILL, JR. (TIP O'NEILL)
THE BIG DIG/FREDERICK SALVUCCI
GAO XINGJIAN: CHINA'S FIRST
NOBEL LAUREATE IN LITERATURE JANIS JOPLIN/THE LAST
CONCERT"CENTER"> MORE ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
Yeltsin explains his
farewell
Public Affairs, 432 pp., illustrated, $26
Coming: HERE BE GIANTS the book.
COMMENTS WELCOMED -- PLEASE CONTACT: GWENDOLYN STEWART
© Copyright 2012 Gwendolyn Stewart. All Rights Reserved.